Mary Whitt
Submit a Review
  • 5 stars
    76
  • 4 stars
    0
  • 3 stars
    0
  • 2 stars
    0
  • 1 stars
    0

5 out of 5 based on 86 ratings.
66 user reviews.
Includes 10 Rate My Agent reviews
Property

Mary was the best realtor we have had! she was very responsive and patient. She knew exactly the right things to do/say and guided us in every step of the process.

Evan Meckstroth

Mary went above and beyond to help us find exactly what we were looking for and did everything in her power to help us get it. She was always quick to respond to questions, get us tours, and advocate for us directly with the listing agents. Always felt like she was on our side and really wanted what was best for us.

Sophia Beaudet

Mary is wonderful. Went the distance to help me sell my condo.

Julie Nuss
Property

Mary is wonderful. Went the distance to help me sell my condo.

Julie Nuss

Great experience.

Jordan Rauch
Property

Great experience.

Jordan Rauch

Mary was amazing to work with! She helped us navigate a difficult move from Illinois to Ohio and always made sure to show us properties that fit the criteria we were looking for. She went above and beyond for us during this process and I would absolutely use her again and refer her to anyone!

Brittany Bashor

She is extremely knowledgeable of the Columbus market and very personable.

Jennifer Whitt

Mary assisted us with selling in a tricky and time sensitive situation and found us an above market deal. Her guidance and expertise helped us achieve our goal while navigating potential risks.

Alex Khadr

This is the 4th home Mary has helped me purchase and each time she provides exemplary service and real-estate knowledge. I would never buy or sell a home with anyone else.

Julie Nuss
Property

This is the 4th home Mary has helped me purchase and each time she provides exemplary service and real-estate knowledge. I would never buy or sell a home with anyone else.

Julie Nuss

Mary was a great help with finding a house for me.

Brandon Valentine

Could not have had a better realtor. Thank you Mary. I wish everyone was a Mary.

Zachary Fitchner

Mary was very knowledgeable and very helpful during the entire home buying process. She was always easy to get ahold of and explained every little thing to us. We loved working with her!

Lara Treneff

I Chose Mary Whitt and I would definately choose her again! She is Extremely Good at what she does and she made us feel like we were her top priority! I will continue to tell anyone who needs a realtor to go with the Best, Mary Whitt, Cutler Real Estate! Sincerely and with Our Deepest Thanks, The Balzanos

Cynthia Balzano
Property

I Chose Mary Whitt and I would definately choose her again! She is Extremely Good at what she does and she made us feel like we were her top priority! I will continue to tell anyone who needs a realtor to go with the Best, Mary Whitt, Cutler Real Estate! Sincerely and with Our Deepest Thanks, The B... Read More

Cynthia Balzano

These are my responses

Charlene Whalen

Mary has always helped make this process as seamless as possible. She’s helped us in multiple endeavors and we are so grateful to know her!

Christy Pittman
Property

Mary has always helped make this process as seamless as possible. She’s helped us in multiple endeavors and we are so grateful to know her!

Christy Pittman

Marry is wonderful, we would recommend her first , over any other company we’ve previously worked with, she will make it happen.

Kennard Johnson Bey

Highly recommend! Mary is quick and helped to explain everything that I didn’t understand.

Racheal Rine
Property

Highly recommend! Mary is quick and helped to explain everything that I didn’t understand.

Racheal Rine

Mary made the selling process go smooth and quick! I appreciate all her help during the process !

Racheal Rine
Property

Mary made the selling process go smooth and quick! I appreciate all her help during the process !

Racheal Rine

Mary is very knowledgable She helped us navigate the complex dynamics of todays housing market

Michael Whitt
Property

Mary is very knowledgable She helped us navigate the complex dynamics of todays housing market

Michael Whitt

Mary is fantastic!

Lauren Miracle

Mary helped us with a very difficult purchase. She is amazing to work with. This is our second time working with Mary and if for some reason we decided to move again we would go through Mary and Cutler.

Michael Miracle
Property

Mary is fantastic!

Lauren Miracle

She is awesome and honest.

Hugh Pierre Salehi

Mary help us every step of the way.

Laura O'Brien

Mary is great! She is responsive, always available to take calls and answer questions.

Brent Null

Mary Whitt exceeded our expectations in finding our Gahanna condominium. With so few homes in the Gahanna market, Mary focused on reaching out to prospective sellers in an effort to source a home. Her tireless efforts paid off and we successfully closed on April 18th. We are very grateful to Mary for finding this home for us.

Gary Nuss

Mary went above and beyond for us during our home search. The house we ended up purchasing was not even on the market, but Mary went the extra mile. She canvased the neighborhood we wanted to live in and found a homeowner willing to sell us their home. In this challenging market, I'm not sure if we would have closed on a home without the extra effort she put in for us. On top of all that, she was very knowledgeable and was able to answer any questions we had throughout the entire process. We are very grateful for everything she did for us and would recommend her to everyone we know. Thanks Mary!

Alex Treneff

We loved working with Mary, as usual she was polite, friendly and always help us to understand the process since we are new for the country. Even to followup with the Builder in this abnormal time. We are waiting for our closing gift from Cuttler ;) Definitely recommend Mary/Cuttler.

Andre Usier

Mary was very reliable and supportive.

Chiajo Fuoching

Mary helped us purchase our home in 2016. We found her witty, reliable and on top of things. Naturally, she was the one to help us sell the home as we were confident in her ability to get things done. Our home had offers within five days on the market and we successfully sold the home, thanks to Mary. Highly recommend her!

Fnu Dean Teneng

Mary is a 5 star realtor!

Claire Yoder

Mary is a top tier Realtor. She went above and beyond for us through the entire process. She answered texts and calls promptly and we felt that she really cared about our home! I have recommended Mary and will do so in the future as well.

Shannon Long

Mary is a true professional! She sold our rental home quickly and assisted our purchase of another with perfect timing. We found Mary to be personable with great attention to detail. This was our first time working with Mary, it won’t be our last. Would highly recommend her to everyone!! Dennis and Angie Widmayer

Angie Widmayer

Mary was great. Her persistence and kindness helped get me into a home I could afford during a sellers' market. I'm truly grateful.

Christine Iammarino

Mary did a great job managing multiple offers to ensure all parties were happy with the end result. Thanks, Mary!

Craig Rudesill

Thanks Mary! Enjoyed working with you again.

Adam J Roorda

Mary was always able to provide valuable feedback for us in our first home-buying experience. We were able to find the home for us and stay completive with our offers due to her guidance, even in a difficult climate.

Alex Khadr

Mary is very knowledgeable and also very thorough. I would recommend Mary to a friend

Michael Whitt

Mary Whitt helped us find our dream home! We were pleased with her attention to detail, optimism, and engagement throughout our homebuying process.

Delrica Grubbs

It was a pleasure working with Mary. We are new to the Columbus Area and she did a great job showing us around the city and introducing us to several areas of the city. She was patient, knowledgeable, and listened to our needs and request.

Corey Grubbs

Fantastic job, we are very satisfied.

Jeff McNamara

Mary did a fantastic job for us. We were out of town clients and she went above and beyond performing tasks in our absence. She was also an excellent negotiator. She caught many items in the buying process that could have slipped through the cracks. She always kept the entire buying experience moving along. We were able to trust her completely and knew she had our best interest in mind. Buying a house can be extremely stressful but her knowledge of the real estate market turned it into a delightful experience.

Marilyn Khadr

Muffy patiently showed us a lot of houses and explained the current market.

Christine Zimmerman

I would like to recommend Mary to my friends and family.

Judy Shivener

Our home went on the market at one of the most volatile times in recent history. Despite a worldwide pandemic and massive layoffs that effect everyone's bottom line our home sold. Marketing and the persistence of our realtor, Mary Whitt made all the difference. We were offered advice and guidance that was sound and helpful. Her expertise of the area and real estate market are exceptional. We have been very pleased with her contact and knowledge. Thank you for your guidance. We would highly recommend your real estate company to future clients.

Mary Dolan

Mary was attentive, swift and very friendly. She was also very kind in understanding the issues with my home. I was leaving due to a spousal relocation in Illinois. I had been there 18 years (I actually didn't do the math, but she did!), so there was an emotional element, too. We somehow were able to list and sell before lockdown even came up. None of us knew that was coming, of course, but I am so grateful my home sold before lockdown which happened not long after. I will highly recommend Mary Whitt to anyone I know back in Ohio.

Kristin Dienst Braun

Mary exceeded our expectations. She helped us sell our home within a couple of weeks and find our dream home. We would highly recommend her to all our friends and family!

Tim Nuss

I can't thank Mary enough for all of the assistance she provided in helping me find my home. She is a great person and awesome Realtor. I will definitely recommend her to everyone.

Terese T

We enjoyed working with Mary. She was very knowledgeable of the market and provided lots of good information to help us find a great home for a great price!

Kelly Harvey

Thank you for Everything!

Jessica Cater

N/A

Allison Bowman

Mary did an excellent job throughout the buying and selling process. She negotiated on my behalf, while ensuring that I maintained realistic expectations. I recommend Mary to anyone interested in buying or selling.

Shawn Nye

Mary did an fantastic job with helping my wife explorer and kearn about the Colmbus area, so she could find a suitable home for our family. Mary's knowledge and openess allowed for a smooth buying process and a stressless event.

Derrick Bowman

Mary is a knowledgable professional who worked tirelessly to help us sell our house. She was available and accommodating at all times, and it was an absolute pleasure to work with her!

Patricia O'Connor

We had a fantastic home buying experience with Mary Whitt of Cutler Real Estate. We switched to Mary towards the beginning of our home search after receiving sub-par customer service from one of the best-known realtors in the Columbus region. After being told we wouldn't be able to find what we were looking for, we decided to find a realtor who would help us find our dream home. In addition to being knowledgable about the Columbus region, Mary provided amazing customer service and made sure we had a positive home buying experience. I was living on the west coast during our home search, and Mary was kind enough to drive me around Columbus five or six times when I was in town (in rush hour traffic!). We weren't the easiest clients, as we considered building a home at one point during our search only to change our minds back to purchasing an existing home. Mary provided fantastic support and expertise throughout the entire process, despite us being somewhat indecisive. After 3 months, Mary helped us find the perfect home for our growing family and we couldn't be happier.

Ryan Walker

Mary was hands down--the best. Her fun attitude matched with her unlimited wisdom of the market simply made our experience enjoyable. She found us our dream house in less than 24 hours! She genuinely cares for her clients and their needs. If you are looking for a realtor that you want to make a connection with-- You do not need to look any farther!

Georgia Rauch

"We recommend Mary Whitt! She was low pressure and guided us through the whole process. She priced our house perfectly! She gave us her opinion about the price even though we had another idea about pricing -- and guess what,, she was right! Also,, she was an expert on the home photos! She guided the photographer and rearranged furniture -- she did it all! The photos were great. We were very happy from start to finish with our home selling experience.",

Karna Anthony

Mary is one of the best real estate agents I have ever had the pleasure to work with. She was very understanding of my wife's and my desires and worked overtime to make sure our needs were met. We were living out of state it that did not discourage her from giving us her best service like we were her own family. If you get the chance,, definitely give Mary a call and let her find you your dream home!

David Roberts

Mary ROCKS!!

Kevin Robitaille

Mary made the whole process very easy and was incredibly responsive whenever we needed assistance. She's very knowledgeable in her market area and gave us great advice while searching for our home. I would highly recommend Mary to my family and friends and already have.

Nathanial Boyd

Mary makes things easy whether we're buying or selling, and she's very responsive and supportive.

Craig Rudesill

Thank you! Very smooth transaction!

Scott Whitt

Mary Whitt is a fantastic agent. She was very professional,, knowledgeable,, hard-working,, and always available. Through her patience and dedication,, we were able to find a beautiful home that we love!

Patty O'Connor

Mary was extremely helpful and knowledgeable. She was able to answer all of our questions and give our family meaningful advice. I would recommend her to other potential buyers and sellers.

Jordan Rauch

My wife and I decided to buy our first rental property and really needed help and guidance understanding the market to find the best value. Mary did a great job listening to us and directing us to the best opportunities. We ended up with a great property and couldn't have done it without Mary's knowledge and experience. Thanks, Mary!

Craig Rudesill

Mary is a true professional in all aspects. She is knowledgeable, efficient, straight forward, and very helpful with her extensive grasp of the market and it's trends. She was quick to line up appointments to see homes in our desired areas. We would work with Mary anytime. We truly appreciate our new home and the assistance we received to find our new place.

Mary Dolan

We could not have asked for a more knowledgeable,, hard working,, patient realtor than Mary. Simply said,, she is the best. Mary knows Columbus and the surrounding areas well and is extremely knowledgeable about the housing market. She was extremely sensitive to our specific needs and worked diligently to help our family find the right house for us.

Mary Beth R.

Mary was great to work with. She was attentive,, proactive and flexed to meet our needs and schedule. She would always answer our questions quickly and was in constant communication.

Niki Biglione

Mary was very responsive to all questions

William Tolliver

Share Your Experience

The experience you've had in working with me is important. Please take a few moments and share how your experience was so I can share it with others.

Review Submission Form
  • Markets:
  • 1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel